Sunday, 19 August 2018

Not another Forensic!

It would seem that everytime a new chairman or new management is put into a company the first thing that is done is, lets undertake a forensic audit. In the recent past can anyone please count the number of times that forensic audits have been carried out at FELDA/FGV. 

Now before the new Chairman goes off saying, "these bloggers don't know what they are saying etc etc", lets remind ourselves that when entities, especially large ones, operate there are the quarterly reporting, the risk management frameworks, there are both internal and external audits, than there are (most critically) the responsibility on the part of the Board to keep proper books of accounts and to ensure the truth and fairness of these accounts. So when the new broom comes in and immediately says lets have a(nother)forensic audit is he saying the following,

1. That the previous board and management had such flawed policies, procedures and frameworks in place that resulted in quarterly reports that could not be relied upon, a sham. If so than the Board and Management fell foul of the CA 2016 and should be charged for such, why are the regulators keeping quiet?

2. The Internal Auditors would/should have reported to the AC on shortcomings, did the AC not pay attention and not bother about what the Internal Auditors were saying, or was the Internal Audit function so useless, if its the later than its most worrying as I understand that the Head of IA is at another GLC Plantation Group, wonder what internal auditing goes on there.

3.   With regards to the external audits, who are FELDA's external auditors and how long have they been the auditors. Over the last few years the external auditors have introduced in their audit reports key audit matters (KAMs), supposedly matters that keep the auditor awake at night with regards the audit. Have concerns not been raised and highlighted, if they did what action if any was taken, if not what is the Board going to do with regards to  the value that the external auditors provide.

With this wealth of information, including a previous forensic, can someone please explain why the need to flog the dead horse over and over. I am sure the Police and MACC also have their own investigation papers. 

While it may seem the right thing to do, at the end what value do these countless forensic provide, the prize mare has already been abused and the culprit bolted from the barn,  what good is shutting the barn door now! 

Enough of the investigations etc, just get on with it and put things right. The culprits should be reported to the police and hopefully are guest of His Majesty.

STOP THE SANDIWARA, LETs MOVE FORWARD!   
    

Saturday, 28 July 2018

Relevance

relevance definition: the degree to which something is related or useful to what is happening or being talked about.

I believe that from time to time one's publicist or media agent ensures that one remains relevant...............because if you are not than you are forgotten. Additionally being relevant in today's world can make you big bucks, some are relevant in main stream media others are on the alternative media like instagram. Hence today we have sisters that are continuously in the news and it would seem their relevance is the body shape with certain parts being larger than the norm, than there is the lady that never smiles or there is that *^%# star that offers to have a relationship with soccer players.  

The subject of relevance got me to ask if it is for this type of reasoning that certain corporate leaders need to be always in the news, they are not really concerned whether they court the right kind or the wrong kind of news, as long as they are in the news!

Since relevance is of concern, i still want to know;

1. That big discount received on the tax, how was that accounted for in the accounts was it treated as income, or was it treated as a creditor and after two years handed over to the authorities under the unclaimed money act.

2. It was reported that there were shenanigans in the sister company's procurement system, a police report was lodged, we are told, what is the status?

3. Is there an update with regards to your travel status, are you welcomed in all countries of asia and are there some countries that would wish you to visit since they are keen to discuss your business dealings.

4. Would it be premature to congratulate you as the de facto MOT, de facto seem to be another term commonly used in the country, seeing that you are currently making statements on transport infrastructures.

Thank you, looking forward to your next ranting, but will appreciate your replies, via mainstream media.    

Saturday, 21 July 2018

Of Professional Service Providers and Standards of Conduct

Of recent past the auditing fraternity, especially in the UK, has been under intense scrutiny  particularly with regards to their quality of work and their business conduct. Articles have come out in the broadsheets, in some reports it has been suggested that the Big 4 are willing to share their knowledge infrastructure with the Top Ten, probably to thwart the regulators from acting on their stranglehold over their market space.  

Even at home there are growing concerns over their services and the value that auditors give. Recently we came to know that with regards to the audit report of a much talked about state fund, it was not one but two auditors that had retracted their reports. Of course this begs the question as to whether their audits were of so poor quality that they issued reports without satisfying themselves sufficiently. One audit partner told me that the audit files of at least one of these auditors have been with the profession's institute for investigation and that nothing was moving. 

If one is wondering why the AOB has not been involved, again I am told that the AOB had decided that the state fund is not under the sphere of their auditor performance reviews, which I thought strange as performance and standards are performance and standards and the fact that the SC had advocated in their recent MCCG that state and statutory bodies should embrace the MCCG. Furthermore the SC uses the term public interest entities, not plc, so why should not this particular audit not fall under the AOB's purview. 

Concerns therefore about the standards of conduct of these professional service providers are not misplaced. 

Recently the chairman of a big 4 was reported as being made the chairman of the new executive committee of 1MDB and it was reported that this was part of the scope and services. Now if you ask anyone, they would probably scratch their heads and ask how come and probably add "most unusual arrangement, never heard it done before". This begs the question as to how problems will be resolved since the advisory team will be going to one of their own in trying to resolve matters and yet this one of their own must act in the best interest of the company as he is an executive and hence a director! Under any circumstances this is a major conflict of interest. Where would the check and balances that auditors famously like to quote be? 

It reminds me of another instance where similar shenanigans took place, this was at the inception of the AOB. Like all new organisations the AOB needed staff and naturally the profession was tapped. However at the senior level of the AOB, a staff of senior ranking was seconded to the AOB from one of the firms(imagine the laughing emoji here, many of them). Many to this day believe that this was the reason that the firm in question was never hauled up for their non qualification of a glc that lost billions in the middle east. For those interested, the secondee has returned to the mothership and is now a partner earning big money, so who says loss of ethical and moral values does not pay.

Similarly there are those of us waiting for the new BNM Governor to make a statement either endorsing or categorically stating that the professional services firm saying RM7m as a pass through in an account is ok, because if it is, than surely the case against the previous regime for money laundering must be in doubt and it would open up opportunities for another service offering in the financial services industry.

Point: External Auditors must remember that they are people with green pens placing green ticks, they issue reports that are so ring fenced that it is becoming meaningless, they earn a lot of money for this and they should stay satisfied with this opportunity. 

Finally has the MOF and the two SOs thought about this conflict, or have they embraced the philosophy of the previous government: we can also be as arrogant and do as we please, after all we convinced the rakyat to vote us in and as such they will believe us as long as we utter the magic word "1MDB" 

LET'S NOT FORGET THAT PERCEPTION IS 90% OF REALITY.   

Friday, 20 July 2018

The MSW G and Executive Pay.

Executive pay has been the bane of governance for over two  decades. In Malaysia it is not new either and from time to time this becomes a hot issue hitting our front pages.

Two days ago the executive pay of a CEO hit the headlines and for justifiable reasons. The main objectors were institutional investors and the Minority Shareholders Watch Group (MWSG).

Let me be very forthright, my gripe is not with the institutional investors for raising this issue(they have a reason), but more with the MSWG.

As I  said the topic of executive pay is not new, so can the MSWG please provide the following information: 

1. Since their inception how many times have they raised the issue of executive pay on their own, not latching onto the coat tails of others. 

2. Apart from the issue of executive pay, can the MSWG provide instances where they have raised burning issues with regards to governance related matters. I have friends that have labelled the MSWG as a "waste of time" for reasons of their cursory questioning and timidity.

3. Can the MSWG please make a public disclosure on their ownership and funding structure and then provide a list on how many times they raised governance issues in entities that their stakeholders are involved with.

As my friends says, the MSWG is a waste of time, it's like many institutions in Malaysia, nice to have, but when it comes to implementation and enforcement it is a case of hiding under the desk.

PS:

Don't get me wrong, I am all for managing executive pay, but

1. No knee jerk reaction, it must be performance based.

2. Pay international rates even to Malaysians, if need be, if not in future we will continue to complain about the brain drain. 

3. The world has been trying to come to a landing on what is a fair remuneration, but till today cannot do so. Look at the Anglo - Dutch IOC, they made a mistake on the Chairman's remuneration in the early 2000s and the did it again recently. Hence a lot of work and time needs to be put into this area.

4. Finally guys stop attacking the receiver, the culprit are the givers. Its like like when we are caught for a traffic offence, most times its "boleh selesai", its rare that we will accept the summons and pay the fine. After which we complain about our corrupt enforcement agencies.  

In a similar light, why has the Nomination and Remuneration Committee not been taken to task. After all they agreed on the executive package and they were supposedly measuring it and agreeing payment, or was it a case of saving their own seats on the board, so silence was the better route?

So MSWG, do your job, become relevant or else close shop and save your stakeholders the money!  Governance issues are not politics they are factual and many private investors need someone that they can rely on.  

Corporate Malaysia needs an effective watch dog and you are certainly falling very short! 

Tuesday, 17 July 2018

Que Sera Sera Minister of Finance

It's now coming to approximately two months that a new government has been formed and is in-charge of the country. It's about 3 or 4 years since we first learned about all the shenanigans and the 1MDB saga. More importantly it's the opposition that brought this all to the fore and fought very hard to make the  rakyat aware and to convince us to vote out the incumbents.  

But seriously, how much longer does the MoF and his two cohorts need to continuously keep referring to 1MDB, come on get on with it, stop being a scratched record.  Pause and remind yourself that if there was no 1MDB than you guys will still be the opposition!

On the issue of LRT3, can the Rt Hon Minister of Finance please stop talking %^*&, there is a difference between cost cutting and cost management. 

Cost cutting takes place when you do away with parts of the item or completely doing away with it. Therefore removing stations etc, changes the build scope and that results in the cost cutting/reduction. Wow  the country needed a MOF and two machais to do that, something a 5th former could do and they are mighty proud of it!

On the other had if they had applied cost management techniques, by looking at the Bills of Materials and renegotiated with the suppliers and squeezed them and found more ingenious ways of being more efficient and effective, than there is reason to feel proud and to shout from the top of the hill!

So MOF, lets stop the continuous 1MDB or many little 1MDB, we know that, clean up the mess or the rakyat may just not vote you back.  Get down to work! 

Monday, 26 February 2018

The AC and Internal Audit Services.

It's CNY, found myself at Open Houses, one of which I was in the midst of Audit Committee members. After the normal blah blah blah, the topic meandered to the new regulations and what was needed to be done. 

It was very comical, I thought, that AC members did not know that their performance needed to be reviewed by the Nominating Committee and that there were those that thought how ironical it was that they would be reviewing themselves, simply because many companies do not have sufficient independent directors to keep the Nominating Committee and Audit Committee membership separate. Oh well, I suppose there will be some creativity, lets wait and see and see what Bursa will do about it.

More interestingly is when the topic of IA quality reviews were discussed I found out that the IIA(M) was peddling this service! I, as with many professional, find this unthinkable, that an institute formed to promote, educate and certify practitioners of a particular profession would themselves be undertaking the very services that they certify. This would be like the Institutes of Chartered Accountants or The Certified Accountants Associations undertaking statutory/external audits! 

To better understand why this Institute was at odds with the norm, I did my Inspector Clouseau stuff and this is what I found out.

1. Yes the IIA(M) undertakes such because the world IIA body does similarly, so its permitted.

2. Does the IIA(M) have a team of professional staff to undertake the engagements? No the rely on a team of contractors.

3. How does the IIA(M) ensure quality, I am told that it is done via its secretriat that has certifiers!

4. I was further told by my informent, "we don't get involved with this becuase it really is a tick the box approach. So much for looking at the qualitative approach, and the SC saying that the MCCG should not be embraced with a tick the box approach! 

I would even place a wager that the Quality Review is based on the Guidance on Internal Audit Function that can be found on BM's website. Personally I thought it was a very poor document and I was totally surprised that BNM, SCM and BM would lend their name to it, this especially so when BNM in the late 90s came out with a GP on IA that was world class.

Finally I wish AC members all the best as under revised rules they will be required to not only approve the Internal Audit Plan but also the IA Program! 

   

Saturday, 24 February 2018

Its all about impariment

A large shipping company that is intimately involed with the oil and gas industry recently posted siginificantly lower earnings, the main reason given was that they made higher imparment charges in the fourth quarter.

Now what was missing was whether the impairment was only made in the 4th qtr or whether there were impairment charges made in the 1st, 2nd and 3rd qtrs too. I am told by an ex audit partner friend that impairment needs to be accounted for immediately and its not a year end charge! 

If this be the case, than perhaps,

1. That the Corporate Survillance department of the SC needs to review the accounts and provide assurances that the previous quarterly announcements were not false or misleading(possible painting a rosier picture than it is).

2. I was puzzled by the decision of the Board to declare a dividend. This surprised me because a good part of the announcement related to the bleak situation in the o&g shipping industry citing oversupply etc etc and the challenges relating to o&g. 

Sometimes, no, most times I wonder whether good corporate governace is a myth and whether its just spoken of to say "WE ALSO HAVE IT"

       

A case for the Securities Commission

Over the past month we have been informed that in two of the pure play entities not all is as rosy as it is made out to be.

1. We have been advised that all is not well at the Battersea Power Project, that it requires an injection of aproximately RM8b.

2. Recently we have come to read reports that not all is well with the plantation investment in West Africa.

I tried to locate the prospectus, but till now I have not been able to, simply to see is these risks or other information relating to these were highlighted, after all under the disclosure based regime its all about,

  • Governance
  • Disclosure
  • Diligence.

My simple mind suggest to me that if these material inormation were made know than the market would have talked about it or worse the opposition bloggers would have had a field day. So I am going out on a limb and conclude, rightly or not, that such information was not highlighted.

Now if that be the case should the SCM not take action against the promoters and the IBs for witholding material information in the prospectus. 

I cannot honestly say that I expect any answers because those that are privileged are never taken to task and those that are nobodys are normally the ones paying the price to make up the KPIs!     

Friday, 19 January 2018

So we are expected to believe!

All day long friends and the curious have been messaging me with regards to the Battersea Power Redevelopment Project, that the EPF and PNB are buying into the next phase, or so we are expected to believe!

My response to all was the same,

1. Is not PNB the major shareholder of Sime Darby and SP Setia, hence are they not buying what they already own save for the minority.

2. Is the EPF not an original consortium partner?

3. If 1 and 2 are correct than would there not be questions asked with regards to the ethical and moral persuasions to this deal. Have directors of companies not been charged for criminal breach of trust for these types of deals.

4. Now one of the issues that was mentioned for cost escalation were the fact that the four chimmenys need rebuilding and the asbestos issue. For such an old property and taking into consideration that the power station had to be maintained and its age, was not a technical due diligence underaken? What happened to the smart people in Sime and SP Setia, did they not know what they were buying?

5. Who are the lead managers and have they been updating the board?

6. If 5 above is a yes was this information disclosed when Sime was being restructed, if not would not the parties to the restructing have committed an offence under the CMSA?


I can understand that PNB has alot of face saving to do and therefore had to sell what effectively is a bale out disguised as a purchase, but what is the EPF doing, bailing out itself? 

To me its yet again nothing more than another example of incompetency. Maybe we have a long way to go to being a developed nation!

Sunday, 14 January 2018

Who is Accountable?

We all read that The Group wanted to do a group restructuring that involved merging their engineering and their energy vehicles into their holding company. The result was that the engineering company, mired with all sorts of problems voted yes, whilst the energy company which is the healthier of the two said no. 

In corporate exercises of this nature there are a host of advisors, from financial reporting accountants to the independent advisors that vet the data, drawn up the various documentation for submission to the regulators and finally present them to the shareholders to be voted on. 

The curiousity is why were the shareholders of the energy entity, only armed with information presented  to them, astute enough to reject the proposal, was it as the actual the offical line suggest, that oil prices were moving north and as such they did not want the deal, or was it simply that the shareholders thought that they were not willing to use their money to bail out the non performing engineering company, lets not forget that the auditors of the enginerring company issued their last report with a "going concern" reservation, the engineering company has issues with their contracts both locally and abroad, etc, etc.

To me this is a classic case for a governance case study,

1. Did the directors of the energy company discharge their duties and reponsibilities as required by law and in the best interest of the comapny on which they sit?

2. Did all the advisors similarly fulfill their responsibilities as professionals, or were they naive enough to believe if the offer was attractive enough shareholders were bodoh enough to approve the scheme.

3. Did the regulators do their own due d and question the deal in depth. The talk was that all that was happening was using good money to try and cover a sink hole. Are our regulators not pandai enough?

4. What was the single largest shareholder doing, why did they let it happen, were they just interested in letting things go by, its not our problem approach. Since becoming the single largest shareholder they don't seem to have done anything, the same management team that was the cause of the problems are still there. Says much about this corporate shareholder and their perceived reputation for good management.

5. The MSWG too chooses to remain silent. This is a case for them to defend the minorities, who else is there? 

On the surface it seems that from the directors to the advisors to the regulators have questions to answer, but I suppose silence will prevail and nothing happens!

So much for the regulators, the exchange and all those that actually want is to believe that cg in Malaysia is improving!   

Thursday, 28 December 2017

When will the noises (bitching) stop?

“All I and AirAsia have ever tried to do was to make it cheaper for the average man to dream and fly like those with money. One day airports, regulators and politicians will understand,” he said alluding to the controversy over the increase in passenger services charges (PSC) at klia2, which is the main hub for AirAsia.“I’m probably one of the most unpopular men for being outspoken and trying to make flying affordable. But won’t stop till the slogan I came up with in the shower becomes true. ‘Now Everyone Can Fly’. The battle must never stop,” he wrote on his FB page.

How many times have we heard the same scratched record being played. Ironically it's loudest when there is something happening that we are not meant to know, so lets create the smoke screen!  

Now if I want to create a low cost organisation, logic will tell me that there are two costs that I am required to give my attention too, 

A. Cost that are outside my control(external), primarily these are the cost that I incur from my suppliers because I need goods and services. These costs I manage by employing frameworks like Supply Chain Management, Just in Time, Bulk Buying, Long Term Supply Agreements, Heavy Discounting, etc, etc. But ultimately there is a level beyond which the supplier will say, "Sorry ole chap, I cannot do that as I would be making a loss!"

B. Then there are internal costs, cost that are within my control. Again there are various solutions I could employ to keep a tight reign on the costs. I could employ large scale IT systems to increase productivity, making front line personnel cleaners(never thought about the hygiene situation - one minute cleaning, next serving food) keeping head counts to a minimum, doing fanciful things like hedging and getting rid of the trappings of grandeur.   But this will entail leadership and setting the tone at the top, the very top! That means giving up the Bombardier private jet that in itself incurs a bag load of money. After all why should it not be them using their own product, would not the towkays be great ambassadors for the organisation?  

C. The pass through "financial items(costs)" that organisations are required NOT to incur in their own right but are mere de-facto collection agents of other organisations or the government, like PSC(a consumer tax levied on the passenger), GST(a consumer tax levied on the user of goods and services) or PCB( tax deducted at source for salary I the employee earns). These cost have nothing to do with the organisation and its costs structure. Does anyone remember the times when we went to the airport to check in, at the time of checking in we had to hand over cash for our passenger service tax, there are still countries that employ this method. This has nothing to do with the airlines!

So stop all this noise, concentrate on A and B, if you feel that you are not getting what you pay for, than please go talk to MAHB, don't treat your customers as being less informed. Anyway what happened to the Muhibbah Dinner that the organisation had with MAHB?, I suppose MAHB may once again need to suggest making public the debtors position of its various clients!    

For 2018 I hope towkay remembers that not only ‘Now Everyone Can Fly', but also everyone went to school, can read and rationalise. 

Happy New Year Towkays!

Friday, 22 December 2017

Of Youth, Skills and Relevant Experience.

This is what was contained in the filing with Bursa:

"Neelofa Mohd Noor has been at the helm of NH Prima Sdn Bhd for the last 3 years as its director. Under her leadership, the brand Naelofar Hijab is sold in more than 23 countries including Brunei, Indonesia, Australia, UAE, United Kingdom and Europe. As an actress and TV host, she acted in a number of blockbuster movies and hosted popular TV shows. She had also produced her own reality TV show. Neelofa has a strong presence on social media with more than 5 million followers on Instagram. She has received many local and international awards including being listed as Forbes Asia 30 Under 30 Class 2017, SME 2017 Celebrity Entrepreneur of The Year, MSMW 2017 Social Media Celebrity of The Year and In Trend Malaysia InTrend Gala Night 2017 Most Charming Celebrity of The Year, The Inspiring Woman Award and The Iconic Role Model Award. She has been invited to speak at forums and talks, most notably at the 2017 Forbes Asia Summit in Manila, 2017 UNDP-MiSK in New York and 2017 Forbes Summit in Boston. Many international brands like Lancome, Swarovski and Titan have recognised her achievements thus signing her as their ambassador."

Another public interest entity appointed two directors to replace the top man as he was appealing a 5 year prison sentence and a fine for insider trading, one is a 29 year old female the daughter of the man in hot soup, not much information other than academic qualifications, the other is a 39 year old gent, the nephew, again primary information on academic qualifications and that he has been involved with the company since 2000.

My amusement is how both companies can say ( in the case of both ladies) that these appointments meet the requirement of persons with relevant skills and experience that will contribute to the business of the companies. This is not just a requirement of The Malaysian Code of Corporate Governance 2017, but a requirement of CA 2016 with regards to the application of Duties and Responsibilities of Directors.

Needless to say I am sure there are many valid reasons that are unknown to me, I wonder if it includes *%#@ to the r_g______s ? People sometimes forget that a plc is a different kettle of fish, there are fiduciary responsibilities, oh well,Malaysia Boleh.

At the encouragement of BV!

After lunch and over a cup of tea, BV enquired as to what had become of my blogging. I said I thought no one bothered, his response was that I should continue as there were those that read this blog, at least for amusement. So for BV's and others that indulge, I decided I shall make another attempt. 

Tuesday, 7 February 2017

What they don't want you to know!

Chinese New Year, in fact all festive occasions, with the exception of Hari Raya, there is such joviality and happiness brought about by that poison, that tongues get loose and many things are divulged, as they say, caution is thrown to the wind.

One of the stories that I heard is of such repercussions that I am wondering how come we have not heard the crumbling  sound of the whole organisation as it comes crashing down.

Now it seems that when ever a berhad (not just listed berhad, but berhads) solicit funds from the public they need to get permission from the Capital Markets Regulator ("CRM"). Apparently there was such a case where the berhad did not get approval, and naturally the CMR took action. Now here is the intrigue,

1. Apparently the case was thrown out, it seems that the judge thought that the law and or facts were incorrectly applied. Larger issue is, is this only referenced to this particular case or does it effect all future solicitation of funds. Can you imagine, the wider net that it could apply too.

2. Apparently it was handled by a junior prosecuting officer, why a case that had the potential for far reaching ramifications was not handled by the Head of the Department needs to be questioned. Maybe the belief is that since they are the CMR, the judiciary will always grant them what they wish!

3. Now this is the more interesting part, that the defending lawyer was a former employee of the CMR and there are rumblings that some sort of pally relationship exist between the former and current prosecuting officers. Apparently a number of former prosecuting officers have gone on to set up their own legal practise and for some reason specialise in CMR's cases.  I wanted to ask more, but I was afraid if I did that I would have alerted them and that would have been the end of the stories.

I am told that there would be an appeal lodged, but what is ironic is that how could it have happened in the first case. It only adds to what I have been saying, the organisation has become totally dysfunctional with no leadership, more time is spent with opening ceremonies, photo taking and overseas trips. The time has come for change!

Maybe Mr. Tan Sri Dato Seri needs to have people that are willing to challenge his decision and instructions rather then having silence, remember Silence does not mean acceptance (read correct), Only God Can Be Correct All the Time!

Calling a Spade a Spade - The Continuing Sime Darby Fiasco - Update

Just a short note, did you guys notice that on Saturday last and today there were rating agencies being negative on the proposal with regards to separately listing the Plantation and Property Group. I hope that PNB is taking note and will do the right thing. What was it that the late President Kennedy said.

you can fool some people all of the time,
you can fool all of the people some of the time,
But you cannot fool all of the people all of the time!

Truly I hope that the new Chairman and CEO of PNB will do the right thing. The right thing takes time, effort and strength and addresses the root cause of the problem.  After all no pain, no gain.



Wednesday, 1 February 2017

Calling a Spade a Spade - The Continuing Sime Darby Fiasco

So in the late 90s and early 2000s the owners of Sime Darby Berhad started the process of taking public listed entities within the group private. Some suggested that it was to make sure that income flowed totally to the holding without any dilution (by way of minority payments).

Then in the mid 2000s there was the merger with other plantation companies within the PNB group, the saying was that big was beautiful, synergies, economies of scale etc etc etc.

Now since the new Chairman of PNB has come in, its let's re-list property and plantations (I understand the Motor entity was to be included but the numbers are not so good) to unlock value.

Wow within 15 years we are back to another round of list, delist and re-list, (of course the thought did occur to me whether it has equally to do with generating income for the Maybank group).

Now lets be realistic, its time for brutal honesty;

1. Is this really for unlocking value or to hide the fact that the group is a non performing group.

2. Fact remains that the current CEO is a non performing chap, every where he has been too, FELDA, Bank Islam, TH etc etc, he has never enhanced the value, many argue that in fact he left the entity worse off.

3. Reality is that after the Sime/Qatar debacle they have never been able to recover. At that time there was a light weight CEO, he was removed another lightweight was appointed, nothing has changed. Why when almost all the management left/was replaced from the time of the Sime/Qatar but the  CFO still remains puzzles many. Does the CFO not play an important and pivotal part, is the CFO not the check and balance to the CEO, could the CFO not have been more effective then and now, or was the package more alluring that the right thing to do was to be silent and hold on to dear job.

4. Ignoring the fact that the current CEO is really not a toughie, what really happened was Sime went and over geared itself in purchasing NBPOL, and what that means is if you are not an efficient company, eventually you will not be able to meet your obligations.

So Sime was forced to par down its debts by selling prime assets. Lucky for them their PR department was able to sell to the media as a monetisation program.  So now we got this poor performing CEO and lepak CFO being made to look like heros. One must also ask what happened to the much vaunted Risk Management system, they should have spotted red flags.

So cutting the story short, PNB Chairman and CEO, lets face reality, its not a case of unlocking value, its a case of hiding the incompetency of the Board, its CEO, CFO, Risk Management division, oops it looks like maybe the whole group.

You guys don't believe me that the whole system is broken, ask the CEO whether he tried to appoint his buddy as Chief Internal Auditor and when Audit Committee said maybe not, he continued with current one till now, maybe its some new management philosophy!  

So Tan Sri Chairman, to generate real value please put the group right, ring out the inefficiencies and ineffectiveness, it might take some time, you might be surprised that the group will be far more profitable then you imagined.

Maybe to start of you may want to ask why not only the CEO has a BMW 7 series but all his direct reports, why when they travel they travel in entourages etc etc.

Remember nice people do not run performing companies, they run charities! Doing the delist, re-list, delist etc is not addressing the real issues, it only delays the inevitable.
                   

You just simply don't listen! - The AA situation - An Update

Last week there was this long, almost a page,  news report in the financial edge relating to the fact that AAX was quoted in a charge relating to the Rolls Royce ("RR") bribery. The report's opening para said that AA has no relationship or dealings with RR, and claims no knowledge of the matters relating to the USD3.2m graft! All I can say is yes they are correct, AA it would seem has no relationship but sister company AAX did sign to have their A330s powered by RR's Trent engine.

Now we all know that there are two heavyweights (no pun intended) that are instrumental in all major transactions that involve the group. So by saying AA is not involved and stating that there are no relationships with RR is technically correct, we also know that when a statement is made it must be unequivocally clear, especially when it involves a group where management is considered as one by the general public.

Now I believe, in my simple mind, that what AA/AAX should do is to make a very firm denial regarding this matter, appoint a top solicitor and challenge the Serious Fraud Office, after all its reputation is being hung outed and questioned, and I am sure the heavyweights in particular would not want this to happen, especially when they are planning an IPO, or are there reasons that they prefer that remains unknown.

It would additionally be nice if the group would also shed more light regarding the transaction with the Executive jet, yes it was reported that it all went through the Audit Committee, but considering its seriousness it would be good for transparency and it would make interesting reading for the simple mind and demonstrate a high degree Good Corporate Governance.

Considering the seriousness of this matter, I am wondering if Bursa have or will be asking for further clarification! Oh maybe not, since they have this situation of "we have a new CRO, we don't have a new CRO, no no our CRO is still our CRO!

Finally  remember my theory of patterns, there is a single occurrence, then two occurrences, and finally its a way of live..........................people don't fail because they are stupid, they fail when they become arrogant!

Monday, 23 January 2017

OK Guys Its now Comical

Ok guys, I know I am not very good with this blogging thing, my attempt to be cynical sucks, my sentence  construction leaves much to desired and my attempt to garner sufficient readership is failing, but I tell you that I seriously believe in my abilities to smell trouble. Remember my 1, 2, 3 approach to life's occurrences ( well thats all one needs to embrace and it makes you look like a genius), well guess what, its happened again!

Anyone reading these pages will note that I focus quite a bit on the Capital Market Regulator and its front line regulator, simply because I strongly believe that in order for them to be effective they have to be cleaner than clean, beyond reproach.

But I am beginning to believe that these guys are so arrogant that they could not care less! I suppose that they are of the opinion that they are so "powderful' that even if they are caught they can get away with it, or they have not realised that crooks get caught not because they are stupid but because they are arrogant!

In this weekend's Option magazine (a giveaway with the Edge Magazine) is an article under creative enterprise entitled "Empowering via Embellishment", there is a nice smiling photo of the entrepreneur! Its about a chap that is doing online business. In fairness to this chappie, he does say, "What's also been a challenge is balancing my day job and this business - I love what I do so I give it 100% when I'm at work and only do the stuff for XX after hours"........please give us a break! You can 100% segregate yourself while at your day job, wow , you must be the only one on this planet with such abilities. But it is not about this chappie and his business its about the general state of organisational effectiveness of his day workplace!

So once again, Mr. Tan Sri Dato Sri Chairman, not only do you have to put the Capital Market in order (I am sure you have seen and read the double page in today's Sun newspaper regarding one of our top groups. These Indian fellows are simply too persistent)  you also have internal challenges, there simply are not enough hours in the day for you.

Putting all this aside Mr. Tan Sri Dato Sri, out of curiosity can you clarify the following:

1. Does your employment contracts/letters not demand that an employee indulge in other jobs.

2. Is the remuneration so bad, that this example is only the tip of the iceberg, that while you and your entourage jet around to exotic locations, the rank and file need to moon light to make ends meet!

3. Did you and your senior management know of this or were you all spending valuable time working about the confusing designations that the organisation recently applied!

4. Do your people also think there is one set of rules for us and then there are the others!


Once again Mr. Tan Sri Dato Sri Chairman we all eagerly await your responses!

Friday, 20 January 2017

You just simply don't listen! - The AA situation.

When they asked Jesus why he was not accepted amongst his own, his response was that a prophet is always accepted last in his own land. I can never be a religious conscious because I am not worthy enough! But as a start I can certainly try to be a governance conscious!

Now those that have read my pieces will note that I have this 1, 2, and 3 approach to behavioural patterns. If it happens once it's just a mistake, twice means a pattern is emerging and you need to keep an eye on it and if it is three times it's too much of a coincidence, there is a clear cut behaviour that communicates the culture and the ethical and moral persuasion of the organisation.

Now folks, I don't know if you have noted but the Indian authorities have cited the organisation (that likes to dress their serving ladies in bright red) for investigation in RS220 crores in alleged money being paid for issuing a licence via Singapore, I cannot remember if there is also alleged inference to money laundering!

And now in today's UK paper, the Guardian, there is a piece on the Rolls Royce bribery, Thailand, Indonesia and Malaysia is cited. Now guess which company is involved, this is how it was displayed, "Extract from statement of facts on charge that Rolls gave AA executive credits worth USD3.2m for maintenance of a private jet.

Now please remember we must not jump the gun and assume that they are guilty, remember everyone is innocent until guilt is proven.

But what puzzles me is that there seems to be a pattern of questionable behaviour emerging when the group wants to sell its air leasing arm and seek dual listing. To me, the man on the street is,

1. Why has the company not issued any denial of the two situations.
2. Would it not effect the transaction price of the two proposed corporate transactions thereby denying its shareholders better returns.
3. Would the company not be exposing itself to regulatory sanctions and reputational  risk since their Annual Report has a CG statement about their strong respect for good governance.
4. Is this the private jet that was transferred to the company sometime in 2016 burdening the company with unnecessary costs.

What intrigues me is that it's as though this company thinks it can do anything it wants at its own liking and can get away with it, past examples,

1. the passenger service tax saga when they first started, if they got a discount, should that money not have been refunded to the people that paid the tax?
2. We don't like Malaysia, we will move our regional HQ to Indonesia and then quietly with tails between the legs coming back months later.
3. Then the ruckus on klia2 was not being built to our specifications, so we refuse to move, until the airport management company started releasing documents to show otherwise.
4. The GMR saga, at first denials but subsequently and quietly doing some of the things that was highlighted as not done.
5. Further complaints about KLIA2 until the airport operators said they would release info on who the major debtors were. The response was, oh we will have a Muhibbah meal.
6. Then we want KLIA2 name changed.

And now the Indian and RR saga. Whats wrong with these guys, they behave like babies always wanting their way and if not given will sulk!

Tan Sri Dato Seri Chairman, since this is a public interest entity, I believe that at the very least you should demand that your front line regulator ask the company to make clarification, oh dear cannot do that now, got confusion on who is the CRO and not the CRO, hi ya one thing has so much effect on others.  What will people say about corporate Malaysia when the regulators are so ineffective!


        

The promises for a new year - an update

My friend has informed me that whenever there are senior management changes in Bursa it  seems that the SC is required to give it approval, ok, wink, nod or whatever! What he cannot say is whether this is because it is a MOF procedure or a licensing requirement or whatever!

Now the point here is that because (it would seem that) the Tan Sri Dato Seri Chairman has not approved, oked, winked or nodded, there is a state of flux at Bursa about the situation (internally), I was the Chief Regulatory Officer, now I am the Chief Commercial Officer but to the public I am still the Chief Regulatory Officer even though someone else is doing the work of CRO (internally).

Now detractors of our dear  Tan Sri Dato Seri Chairman say that it is typical of the man, that anything sent to him is left on the back burner with the hope that the issue will take its own natural course and magically resolve itself. Some of the more venomous detractors accuse our Tan Sri Dato Seri Chairman of being more interested in overseas travel and opening ceremonies.

Putting all this aside, is there maybe a more serious issue at the frontline regulator (Bursa) of the SC, is there discord within the organisation that the CEO tried his own coup d'etat (by removing the CRO and creating a new position for her - some say a cold storage position), even if that be the case, then there is the situation of the CEO jumping the gun and making internal announcements and senior level movements before exhausting due process! Is this not ultra vires of his office, which should rightly now be referred to for disciplinary inquiry and worse of all, are there multiple cases of constructive dismissal, like the previous case of the Senior Management guy (at Bursa) that had to be paid out in millions, I am told.

Rt. Hon. Mr. Finance Minister, I would put it to you that both the dear Tan Sri Dato Seri Chairman and the CEO of Bursa are proving to be wanting in their abilities, especially in these difficult economic times, and therefore I humbly put myself forward to be the next Tan Sri Dato Seri Chairman.